
“I’m fat and know people treat me differently, regardless of what I wear, so why bother dressing to impress.”
Liz A
Liz A keeps a $300 emerald green prom dress she will never wear. Most days she lives in clearance PJ pants from Walmart, some of them about a decade old. Liz A answered one of our reader surveys, “What’s Actually in Your Closet?” and the answers below are the reader’s own words. She is 33, in the 25–34 bracket, and lives in a suburban part of Arizona with her husband, their kids and her parents.
She is two months postpartum and on maternity leave from a job with a dress code. The numbers are small. She owns under 50 items of clothing and wears fewer than 10 in a normal month. She has under 10 pairs of shoes, nothing with the tags still on, and spends under $500 in a typical year, mostly at Walmart or Target-type stores, Costco and Amazon.
She almost never buys. Her one rule is comfort first, because the wrong cut or fabric can set off a panic attack. Yet her list of ten things to keep is full of stories: a Goodwill dress with pockets, a souvenir hoodie from her study abroad in Florence, and a skeleton hoodie that glows in the dark.
| Where | Arizona, USA |
|---|---|
| Area | Suburban |
| Age range | 25–34 |
| Household | Spouse or partner, Kids at home, Parent(s) |
| Items of clothing owned | Under 50 |
| Worn in a normal month | Fewer than 10 |
| Pairs of shoes | Under 10 |
| Spend in a typical year | Under $500 |
FYI, thanks to AI imagery software, we’re able to create very specific fashion and hairstyle examples to illustrate the points being made. In some cases, imagery is exaggerated to hammer home the point. Also, assume links that take you off the site are affiliate links such as links to Amazon. this means we may earn a commission if you buy something.
If you could keep only 10 things, what would make the cut?
1. Plaid pants (I’m short/petite length and they’re the only pants that don’t drag on the ground)
2. My senior high school tshirt, since it’s been with me since high school
3. Skeleton hoody (it zips up to cover my face as a skull, and glows in the dark)
4. My wedge shoes—it’s the only “high heel” that fits my foot shape and is secured with a removable ribbon, so I can change out the ribbon to match my outfit and it doesn’t hurt my ankle that I broke when I was younger.
5. A fancy dress I wear a couple times a year (black top, large flower print on bottom)—found it at Goodwill 5 years ago; it fits me beautifully, is comfy, and has pockets.
6. Harry Potter hoody—it was a custom gift from my husband’s grandma, is sooo comfy years later, and still fits.
7. My Italy hoody—it’s a slightly tighter fit now, but is the only souvenir I have from my study abroad in Florence
8. A witchy cat tshirt—my husband got it for me at a reptile convention (the same convention we got his carpet python, Corvus, from)
9. My wedding dress—it’s a red and black paisley dress that is appropriate for any fancy or professional event, or just looking nice out and about
10. My fancy, black-jeweled sandals—they’re the only ones I’ve found that fit my feet and are fancy enough to wear with a dress or slacks or even jeans
Who are you dressing for?
I dress for me for the most part—mainly in the don’t-give-a-fuck clothes that I’m comfortable in. I’m fat and know people treat me differently, regardless of what I wear, so why bother dressing to impress. The exception is when I dress for my husband, as a kind of treat or preview for the night or just when I want to surprise him and have him see the sexier side of me
Was there a year, or a moment, when the way you dress changed?
During different stages of life. In college, I dressed in Tshirts and PJ pants, cause they gave away a lot of free shirts. In grad school, I dressed in nice shirts and skirts, and nice dresses that worked for office work and bar hopping. A few years after grad school, I dropped a lot of weight and started wearing more leggings and sexy dresses. Once I had kids though, I gained a bunch of weight back and went back to tshirts and pj pants, because (unless my husband and I are doing a fancy date), who gives a fuck how I look—I wanna be comfy

What did you wear at 30 that you’d never wear now? What do you miss about it?
I’m only 33, so I still wear the same stuff. But the stuff I wore a decade ago that I wouldn’t wear now would be tunics and “older” lady things, since it was department store clothes that fit me (think Macy’s, JC Penny’s, Dillards, etc). I didn’t realize when I was younger that the clothes were part of why everyone always thought I was like 20 years older than my actual age. I do miss the colors and lack of words/branding now, though—hard to find nice, simple, but colorful clothes in modern cuts now, but no regrets
What’s your rule for getting dressed, the one you never break?
Comfort first. I’ve had it too many times where I’ll try to wear something that looks nicer and is more professional looking (or not raggedy like my pj pants and tshirt), but because of the cut or fabric gives me a panic attack (I sometimes have sensory issues, particularly with clothes)
What Our Readers Say
- In our reader polls, 63% of ThreadCurve readers said comfort comes first when they get dressed, while 37% put polish first.
From ThreadCurve reader polls and votes.
What’s the most expensive thing you own that you never wear, and why is it still there?
An emerald green ball gown prom dress. Cost about $300 and won’t ever get rid of it because prom was a good memory….and it cost $300
Does anyone comment on what you wear or what you spend?
The only people that really comment on what I wear are my parents and the occasional coworker. My parents tend to comment on how I look a bit raggedy and should dress nicer and wear jeans more (the comments have lessened as I got older). My husband HAS said he wishes I would wear jeans more since he loves how I look in them, but I rarely do since they’re sooo uncomfortable for me (have been since I was a kid). My coworkers usually only comment when I dress a bit nicer, and it’s usually a back-handed compliment, like how they didn’t know I could look so nice

What’s the hardest thing to find in your size or for your body, and where have you looked?
Shoes that fit my feet. I wear 9/9.5 in a wide/extra wide and I have flat feet. So it’s very difficult to find a shoe, particularly nice looking heels or ballet flats, that will fit my length, width, and comes WITHOUT high arches (they hurt and dig into my feet)….I usually hate shoes and will be barefoot every chance I get
When we asked ThreadCurve readers about daily shoes, sneakers came out on top at 51%, with flats at 29% and low heels at 20%.
What would you tell your 30-year-old self about clothes?
Don’t buy something because someone else says you look good—if you’re not comfortable in it, you’ll never wear it. Buy something because YOU think you look good and makes you feel good about yourself
Describe the outfit you wear most often, piece by piece. Where’s each thing from?
Black/Halloween holiday shirt I got on clearance from Walmart
Some PJ pants (also clearance from Walmart like a decade ago) that are black, plaid, or ghost pants (jeans if I am working)
Underwear I bought in the last year (JoySpun/Walmart boy shorts)
Socks (Hanes black crew cut) that my husband and I both wear and buy new each year
If I’m wearing a bra, it’s a sports bra I’ve owned for like a decade
What’s one thing about clothes or shopping that you think you’ve figured out?
As long as you’re not absolutely committed to a specific outfit, just regularly check the clothing departments when you go shopping, make note of what you like, and track the prices. Most stores in my experience will change the types of clothes at least four times a year (usually between seasons, like prom, summer, Christmas, etc) and the couple weeks before they put out the new clothing, they’ll mark down nearly everything. This mainly applies to stores like Walmart or Target, but department stores typically follow the same seasons. It works especially well for kids’ clothes, jackets/sweaters, and dresses. That and the typical get a bunch of interchangeable items—like my black sandals that will go with damn near any outfit.
She’s in good company: in our reader polls, 63% of ThreadCurve readers said they prefer to shop in store rather than online.
What do you look like in your head versus in the mirror?
In the mirror, I usually look how I am in my head, maybe a little chunkier, but I’m also only 2 months postpartum. In photos, I tend to look heavier, but younger than I imagine—the few wrinkles I have aren’t as visible in photos like they are in the mirror
Which piece gets you the most compliments?
Probably my skeleton shirts and hoody—most people think they’re pretty cool and I agree (it’s why I bought them). I don’t really get compliments on my fancier clothes, usually just my graphic tees
Tell me about the last thing you returned, and why. The last thing you bought and the last thing you regret too, if you like.
If this is strictly clothing related, I’ve never returned anything. If it’s a cut or fabric I don’t usually wear, I’ll try it on in the fitting room and either get it or put it back depending on how it fits. The last clothing I bought for myself was a Halloween shirt, since it was a design I liked (black shirt with orange Jack o lantern face from Walmart). Before that, it was probably our yearly sock purchase or clothes for the kids (Halloween costumes). We usually buy cheap clothes from Walmart that are the same cut and fabric, so we already know what sizes generally fit us.
How do you feel about…
| Who | |
|---|---|
| Getting dressed on a normal weekday | Neutral |
| Trying things on in a fitting room | Avoid it entirely |
| Being in a photo | Dread it |
| Catching yourself in a shop window | Avoid it entirely |
| Shopping online late at night | Neutral |

Shared by Liz A
