ThreadCurve readers have been voting on denim: a heart or a thumbs-down under every photo in our articles on jeans, denim jackets, long denim skirts and denim dresses. We’ve pulled it into one report: 23,373 votes from 3,933 readers on 632 photos, the reasons readers gave, and 4,188 poll answers.
Readers say sneakers, but they heart boots

Denim outfits with boots drew 76% hearts, ahead of every other shoe; sneakers drew 60%. Yet in our site-wide poll on shoes with jeans, 36% picked sneakers and 24% boots. The looks that won also leaned on knits and warm colours: knit-led outfits drew 78%, and beige or tan next to the denim 76%, against 53% for black.
Straight and bootcut beat wide leg

Wide-leg looks drew 65%, below straight (73%), bootcut (77%) and skinny (81%). The polls agree on wide leg: only 11% pick it, against 50% for straight and 26% for bootcut.
Same skirt, 27 outfits
One article restyled the same long denim skirt 27 ways. Soft Coastal Layers With a Wrapped Linen Sash drew 98% and cashmere and denim: an unlikely pairing that works 96%; gallery opening in charcoal and a structured white shirt drew 3%. Every restyling with black or charcoal as the second colour drew below 40%, and every one with loafers below 25%; the top six paired the skirt with white, cream, camel or rust, though two restylings built on a crisp white shirt also landed near the bottom (3% and 22%).
Soft Coastal Layers With a Wrapped Linen Sash
Cashmere and Denim: An Unlikely Pairing That Works
Modern Prairie in a Cream Fisherman Knit and Riding Boots
City Editor Polish With a Belted Blazer and Loafers
Menswear Polish With a Tailored Vest and Loafers
Gallery Opening in Charcoal and a Structured White Shirt
Each photo shows the same starting outfit above the restyled one, so the votes compare the restylings. The restyled photos were also shot in different settings, from warm rooms to bare white studios, and the setting may play a part.
The single photos readers rejected most: bad tucks

Shirts tucked so they pull, balloon or bunch drew almost no hearts. As whole articles, wide-leg mistakes drew 24%, the tuck article 30%, double denim 32% and skinny-jeans styling 32%. Yet in our poll 59% pick tucked over untucked: a neat tuck still worked, like double-layered blouse tucked into slim bootcut jeans (88%).
The photos readers loved most
Soft Coastal Layers With a Wrapped Linen Sash
Indigo Bootcut Jeans + Ivory Cable Knit
Dark-Wash Straight Jeans + Camel Turtleneck
Cashmere and Denim: An Unlikely Pairing That Works
Cream and Brown Let Denim Sit Between Two Softer Neutrals
Modern Prairie in a Cream Fisherman Knit and Riding Boots
And the ones they rejected
Gallery Opening in Charcoal and a Structured White Shirt
Menswear Polish With a Tailored Vest and Loafers
Three Layers Under Denim Should Be Too Much. Somehow, They Aren’t
Cream Texture and Chocolate Make Denim Look Surprisingly Refined
City Editor Polish With a Belted Blazer and Loafers
Sharp Contrast in a Crisp White Shirt and Statement Belt
The full report
The Denim Report pools the photos by leg shape, rise, shoes, colour, fabric, silhouette, neckline, season, price look and print, ranks the most- and least-loved looks and the denim mistakes, and adds why readers voted the way they did and 13 polls. It includes the full dataset.
Get the full report at StatwrenHow we did this
- Readers tapped a heart or a thumbs-down under each photo in 18 of our denim articles between Feb 20, 2026 and Nov 18, 2026. One vote per reader per photo.
- Votes are anonymous: no names, emails or accounts. Readers were reacting to photos, not the garments in hand.
- Percentages are the share of hearts. Traits such as leg shape and rise were read from each photo; article groupings are ours.
- More on how we collect reader data: How our reader data works.
